| 2021 | Rylan Simpson |
| 2020 | No Festival |
| 2019 | Hannah Pugh |
| 2018 | Carllison Blais |
| 2017 | Sarah Bredeweg |
| 2016 | Kara Parkes |
| 2015 | Madison McNeely |
| 2014 | Anna Kluender |
| 2013 | Mia Burton |
| 2012 | Brittany Blanton |
| 2011 | Emily Karr |
| 2010 | Besty Mundy |
| 2009 | Katie Burton |
| 2008 | Lisa Buschmann |
| 2007 | Arin McIntosh |
| 2006 | Kelsey Terrell |
| 2005 | Alyssa Super |
| 2004 | Caitlin Goldsberry |
| 2003 | Jodi Ann Shapuruas |
| 2002 | Jennifer Slone |
| 2001 | Jessica Jones |
| 2000 | Diane Cessna |
| 1999 | Elizabeth Wintczak |
| 1998 | Terra Johnson |
| 1997 | Danielle Peets |
| 1996 | Heather Burgi |
| 1995 | Dialevash Sullivan |
| 1994 | Jennifer Hensley |
| 1993 | Teresa Rush |
| 1992 | Heather Cahill |
| 1991 | Jodi Asbery |
| 1990 | Candace Ellis |
| 1989 | Carrie Robbins |
| 1988 | Stormi Coulter |
| 1987 | Beth Robison |
| 1986 | Kellie Allen |
| 1985 | Greta Blackwell |
| 1984 | April Wilson |
| 1983 | Tracy Mundy |
| 1982 | Missy Brown |
| 1981 | Amy Box |
| 1980 | Donita Ramey |
| 1979 | Julie Pace |
| 1978 | Tammie Wilson |
| 1977 | Susie Wilcox |
| 1976 | Carol Edwards |
| 1975 | Patrice Buher |
| 1974 | Kelly Baker |
| 1973 | Julie Blackwell |
| 1972 | Deborah Jereb |
| 1971 | Joni Hargesheimer |
| 1970 | Gale Briscoe |
| 1969 | Jan Worley |
| 1968 | Susie Hatfield |
| 1967 | Cindy Acton |
| 1966 | Coralee Robison |
| 1965 | Sandra Wilcox |
| 1964 | Carol Cole |
| 1963 | Janice Matthew |
| 1962 | Pasty Williams |
| 1961 | Vicky Walker |
| 1960 | Sandra Reed |
| 1958-59 | No Contest |
| 1957 | Judy Kelly |
| 1956 | Jane Bruner |